How a service business can rebuild its value, and the story behind its fees, around judgment and the client experience
The short answer: As AI takes over the processing in service work, clients will stop paying for tasks and start paying for judgment and experience. The professionals who do well will act as fiduciaries, owning decisions in the client's interest, and as experience curators, shaping how the work feels. They won't be functionaries, people who process the tasks AI can increasingly do.
A past client texted me recently. I'd helped them sell their home and buy a new one a few years ago. Their business had done well, and they wanted to upgrade again: buy a lot and build. Attached was their entire ChatGPT conversation, the research already done and packaged.
My read: they weren't asking me to find anything. That part was finished before they texted. What they needed was someone to help them make the decision well.
That's going to be normal. So it's worth being precise about what a client like that is actually paying me for.
My guess: AI ends up doing most of the job
Here is a prediction, not a statistic: my guess is that AI will end up doing something like 75% of what an agent does today. That includes the research, much of the negotiating, and filling out the contracts. I could be wrong about the number. I don't think I'm wrong about the direction.
Some of it is already here. On a negotiation, I asked AI to study the transaction. It came back with a detail I may have missed: the home had been listed three years earlier, taken off the market, and put back on. Then it suggested three different ways to approach the negotiation.
If AI can do the research and draft the strategy, the question for any service business is simple: what's left that a client would pay a professional for?
The Fiduciary Line
The Fiduciary Line divides the work you process for clients, which AI will increasingly do, from the decisions you own with them and the experience you shape for them, which is what they'll keep paying you for.
Below the line is functionary work: gathering, comparing, drafting, filling in, scheduling. Above the line are two roles. A fiduciary acts in the client's interest and owns the call, including the uncomfortable ones. An experience curator decides what the client sees, when, and in what form, so a stressful process feels handled.
Every service professional is choosing which side to build on. A functionary's value is throughput, and throughput is exactly what AI is getting cheap at.
What a fiduciary does that AI doesn't
Tells the truth about trade-offs, even when it costs a fee. Sometimes clients with a low mortgage rate on their current home are better off keeping it as a rental than selling, and the honest move is to walk them through the math. "I know this might not be fun talking yourself out of listings, but sometimes it's the right thing to do." A functionary has no reason to say that sentence. A fiduciary has no reason not to.
Uses AI as a second opinion and still owns the call. On pricing, I find AI useful as a second layer of perspective, a way to look at the same decision from a different angle. That's all it should be. AI doesn't have our nuanced understanding of a neighborhood, and it may not have seen the interior photos that make a comparison a swing.
So I always give clients a range, tied to timing: how quickly they want to move versus whether they're willing to wait for a specific number. "It's nice to get a second opinion, essentially, from AI, but then ultimately it still comes back to us to make the final call." And pricing a home well above what's realistic doesn't help a client whose real goal is to sell, however much they'd like to hear the higher number.
Is open about how AI is used. One agent in our community told a client up front that they were using AI for the market analysis instead of calculating everything by hand. The client said they'd expect that. In my experience, clients respect it. Some of our top agents now include one page in their listing and buyer presentations: what AI does in their process, what it can't do, and the human element they bring. Hiding the tools makes you look like a functionary with something to hide. Showing them makes your judgment visible.
What an experience curator does
Some time ago a client's new-build lot turned into a problem. They drove out and found a utility box placed in the front of their lot. They hadn't known about it and were upset. They said they'd have chosen a different lot.
I asked the builder's agent to send photos instead of driving out. I took them to AI and had it create mockups of how the home could look with different treatments around the box, like planters, compared with what was currently planned. I told my clients plainly that these were AI-generated and not a perfect representation. They wrote back thanking me, said the images helped, and chose the option with planters.
AI made the mockups. Deciding to make them, choosing the options, being honest about what they were, and sending them before the situation blew up is curation. The tool made it cheap. Judgment made it timely.
The same thinking applies to the routine parts of a process. A simple timeline that shows clients what happens next, and coaches them through it before they have to ask, is a tool I think is worth building. The steps are functionary. Deciding that clients should never wonder where they stand is curation.
Curation is the part clients will keep paying for, and people already pay for it in plenty of other places. A first-class seat lands at the same airport at the same time as coach. A cheaper hotel than the Ritz-Carlton still has a bed and a shower. People pay more anyway, because there's a premium in how a result feels, not just the result.
A service business works the same way. Whatever share of the work AI ends up doing, a functionary is selling that share, and its price will keep falling. Above the line, the fiduciary owns the decisions and the curator owns how the process feels: knowing what comes next, fewer surprises, someone who's been through it before. That feel is the premium. I go deeper on what experience means in a service business, and why people pay for it, in a separate piece on the experience curator. Here, the point is practical: if experience is part of what you're paid for, your business has to be built around it.
How to restructure your business around the line
Sort your work. List what you do for a client from first call to finish. Mark each item as processing (below the line) or decision and experience (above it). My guess is most owners will find the bulk of their hours below the line.
Move the processing. Hand below-the-line work to AI and your team as fast as you can document it. The goal isn't fewer people. It's that your people and your own hours move up the line with you. If that work still lives only in your head, start with how to fix the handoff problem.
Spend the recovered time above the line. More time on the trade-off conversations, the second opinions, and the moments where a client is anxious. That's where a fiduciary earns trust and where a curator earns referrals.
Rewrite the story behind your fee. If you defend your fee with a list of tasks, you're asking clients to compare you with software. Describe instead the decisions you'll own, the trade-offs you'll be honest about even when it costs you, and the experience you'll run. Then show them the one-page view: here's what AI does in my process, here's what it can't, here's what I do. The fee stops being a price for processing and becomes a price for accountability.
What the line costs
Some clients only want the processing, done cheaply, and they'll find software or a discount provider for it. Let them. A business built above the line is built for the clients who want judgment, and it should be described and priced for them, not for everyone.
This isn't only about real estate
Swap in your own business. A bookkeeper whose categorization is automated becomes the person who tells the owner not to take the loan. An insurance broker whose quotes are pulled automatically becomes the one who tells a client which coverage they'll regret skipping.
Where to start this week
Take your last three clients and list everything you did for each. Draw the line. Then rewrite the first paragraph of how you describe your service so it talks only about what's above the line, and see if it still sounds worth paying for. If it doesn't, that's the work.
FAQ: value, fees, and AI in service businesses
What's the difference between a functionary and a fiduciary? A functionary processes tasks: research, paperwork, scheduling. A fiduciary acts in the client's interest and owns the decisions, including the uncomfortable ones. AI is getting good at the first. What clients will keep paying for is the second: experience, judgment, and someone who stays involved when it gets hard. When AI handles the processing, that becomes the whole job.
Will AI make service professionals unnecessary? My guess is AI will do most of the processing. What it doesn't do is own the call, weigh a client's goals against a market, or shape how a stressful process feels. Those are the parts clients will keep paying a professional for.
How do I work with clients who bring their own AI research? Welcome the research and build on it. Be open about how you use AI, show what it can and can't do in your process, and put your effort into the decisions and trade-offs the research can't settle.
How should I talk about my fee when AI does more of the work? Stop defending it with a list of tasks. Describe the decisions you'll own, the honesty you'll bring when it costs you, and the experience you'll manage. Price the accountability, not the processing.
Get the next one. In the newsletter I share how I'm moving my own work above the line, and what I'm handing to AI. Join the newsletter
About me: I'm Shoney Ivens, CEO of a brokerage that's produced over $5.4B in sold real estate volume in the last 5 years.
Want help sorting your business around the line? That's the work inside The Leverage Collective, where we install these systems in 90 days for established agents, team leaders and business owners. See if it's a fit